A Better Way of Renting Cars?

A Better Way of Renting Cars?

When I was a (nerdy) kid, disruptor was a term I tended to associate with

When I was a (nerdy) kid, disruptor was a term I tended to associate with those green energy weapons mounted on Klingon and Romulan spaceships — the alien equivalent of the phasers on the starship Enterprise, with which said cultures would occasionally exchange blasts in some sort of interstellar kerfuffle before Captain Kirk or Picard found a way to smooth things over.

Here in 2023, however — where, fun fact, we’re actually closer to Kirk’s five-year mission than the start of the Revolutionary War — disruptor tends to refer to a company that’s seeking to upturn a long-established, often-stagnant business model. And by that definition, the rental car industry is ripe for disruption.

As if the dot-matrix printers scree-scree-ing out contracts with tear-off flanks in their offices wasn’t metaphor and proof enough, the last couple years have revealed the traditional car-rental model as more flawed than a junk diamond. When the pandemic hit, rental car agencies across America closed their doors and sold their fleets, assuming an end to travel as we know it — only to be caught with their pants down when people began traveling en masse again, forcing them to buy up as many cars as possible, thus in part leading to the car shortages and used-car price inflation that dog us to this day. On top of that, some Hertz customers have found themselves with a particularly severe case of buyer’s remorse after being arrested and even imprisoned for allegedly stealing cars they both paid for and returned correctly. (It grew to be enough of an issue that in 2022, Hertz was forced to pay out $168 million to settle claims brought by those falsely accused of theft.)

Enter Turo. Founded in 2010 as a pseudo ZipCar competitor before pivoting to its current business model, Turo is often referred to as “the AirBnB of cars,” and that’s a pretty accurate way to describe it. Private car owners — I suppose you could call them “hosts” — post their vehicles on the service, offering others the chance to rent them for a short-term period. Turo simply acts as an intermediary (for which, of course, they take a fee); you’re booking with an individual, not a faceless corporation that might forget you returned your car and send law enforcement after you.

The selection of vehicles also can be much more varied — which can be a boon both for enthusiasts and those who like to plan extensively. While traditional rental car companies only offer broad categories when booking, Turo lets you know the exact car you’ll be driving — year, make, model and options.

At least, that’s the idea. To find out how well it works in practice, I tested Turo out on two separate occasions: once during a trip to Montana in the winter, and then on a trip from New York City out to Montauk in the summer. Here’s what I found.

Step 1: Booking with Turo

As with AirBnB, you can use Turo on your browser, although it’s still worth downloading the app to your smartphone; once you’re onto step 2, you’ll need it (for reasons that will become clear shortly). I found using the website on my desktop easier for browsing purposes, as it’s a bit easier to compare different vehicles in different tabs.

For my trip to Montana, I knew I needed something with both snow tires and four- or all-wheel-drive, what with the fact that my route involved navigating tight mountain passes in Arctic conditions. As it turns out, both are checkable options found under the “more filters” section of the Turo website, along with a bevy of other choices — everything from wheelchair accessibility to Apple CarPlay / Android Auto compatibility to ski racks. There are also options to filter by seating capacity, type of car, transmission, year, even for “green vehicles” (EVs or hybrids). Or, if you want to go real granular, you can even look for specific makes and models.

For my Montana trip, I found a match in the form of a 2019 Subaru Impreza 5-door listed by a fellow named Ben. After filing a request to book, we corresponded using the Turo app’s built-in message feature; Ben, who turned out to be a very kind fellow, not only walked me through the pick-up procedure in careful detail, but also provided some local restaurant recommendations, which wound up coming in handy.

A Better Way of Renting Cars?

Ben’s Subaru, which proved a trusty, faithful companion during my trip to Montana.

Will Sabel Courtney

For my New York journey, I had a little help from the good public relations team at Turo, who were setting up the jaunt to showcase the brand. They recommended a Lucid Air for my drive (in part, I believe, because they were excited to see it in person), and connected me with a Turo listing for one. Unlike the Subaru loan in Montana, the Lucid was owned by a booking company that runs a small fleet of Turo rentals in NYC. It’s not an uncommon practice — a lady in Miami reportedly scaled up her Turo fleet to 69 cars — but it definitely makes things a bit less personal.

lucid air

The Lucid Air. Not only does it deliver the shocking acceleration we’ve come to expect from top-end EVs, it also achieves outstanding range — and looks great as it goes along.

Will Sabel Courtney

Step 2: Picking up the car

There are a couple ways you can take receipt of your Turo rental. If you’re going to an airport, it’s common to have the vehicle dropped off at a parking lot, which is how I received delivery of the Impreza in Montana. In that case, owner Ben was able to remotely unlock the Subaru using the MySubaru app on his phone, even though he was several miles away. In the case of the Lucid, since I was grabbing the car in Manhattan, the host had one of its employees bring it directly to me in the heart of the city — which was far more convenient than me venturing up to the Bronx to grab the car from the host directly. (Be aware, by the way, that many hosts may charge you an additional fee for the convenience of an airport drop-off or a direct one.)

Before climbing aboard in either case, however, I had to document the car’s current status — which, in the case of a Turo loan, means taking pictures of it from all angles.

This turned into the sole pain point of my Montana trip; not because taking the pictures itself was a hardship, but rather, because the Bozeman Yellowstone International Airport parking lot is very much open to the elements, which, upon my arrival, meant “windy and -6º Fahrenheit.” Suffice it to say, doffing my gloves and snapping a dozen-plus pictures of a car was not my fingers’ favorite activity.


Both host and borrower are required to upload pictures to the app.

Will Sabel Courtney

Once aboard with the heater cranked and the heated seats blazing, though, life was good. Ben was not only kind enough to leave a few dollars aboard to let me pay my way out of the parking garage, but also left some snacks and water in the car for me, as well. The car itself proved an excellent fit for the Montana winter, starting quickly and easily even in sub-zero temperatures and providing steady, measured grip even when driving over the nightmare surfaces of wind-blown snow and ice along 9,000-foot mountain passes. Also, as a side benefit, I got 35 miles per gallon.

In the case of the Lucid, the dropoff was slightly less smooth, but not directly due to any Turo-related issues. The host informed me the morning the loan commenced that the car needed a little extra time to charge, which pushed the arrival time back around 45 minutes. Or rather, it would have, were it not for the everpresent living nightmare of the Manhattanite: gridlock. Heavy midday traffic added nearly another hour to the driver’s arrival. Luckily, I wasn’t in a rush, but had I been, I likely would have been rather irritated. (Then again, a constant state of irritation is the Manhattanite’s natural state.)

lucid air int

Also, in all honesty, being able to climb into this interior made it a lot easier to deal with the stress of traffic.

Will Sabel Courtney

Step 3: Returning the car

Returning the car was effectively like the pick-up in reverse. With the Subaru, there was slight addition of having to stop for gasoline a few miles from the drop-off point to make sure the car had as much fuel as when I picked it up; with the Lucid, I paid an extra fee to not have to return the car with a full-ish charge, considering how tricky fast charging is in the city. (Helping out matters: the hotel where I was staying in Long Island offered complementary Level 2 charging overnight.)

Drop-off was easy in both cases, however. In Montana, following Ben’s instructions, I took another onslaught of pictures to prove the car was still in the shape I found it, locked the keys in the car at the airport parking lot and messaged him with the location for his later retrieval. In New York, another employee of the host came and met me on the street, where I handed off the key — or rather, the Lucid’s vaguely car-shaped lozenge of a remote.

Is renting a car through Turo better than using traditional agencies?

I’m basing this on just two experiences, but I’d have to say: hell yes. The other journalist on my Montana trip wound up booking a generic SUV through a traditional rental car agency, presumably expecting he’d get something capable — but wound up with a front-wheel-drive Mitsubishi Outlander Sport on cheap all-season tires.

Of course, as with sites like AirBnB, the pricing can vary based on all sorts of factors, some of which are rather opaque. The sum total of my two-day reservation in Montana, for example, came to $350.49; most of that came in the form of the $95/day rate for the car, but there was also the $38/day insurance (I went for the “standard protection” plan, one of three options), a “trip fee” of $16.32/ day (which appears to be Turo’s cut, and is variable based on the other costs of the loan) and an “airport fee” of $31.86, which apparently goes to the airport where the drop-off is conducted. All told, that was a bit more than the other journalist paid for his traditional rental — but your experience may vary, as I’ve also heard tales of Turo options being cheaper than regular rental cars.


Here’s what you’ll see once the trip is complete.

Will Sabel Courtney

Still, given rental car issues both acute and chronic, even paying a little more for the peace of mind of knowing exactly what car you’ll have — and having a direct line to an actual human being in case of issues — seems worth it. Perhaps the best endorsement I can give is this: I’ve already booked a rental car on Turo for my next personal trip later this year. It’s just that much easier.